2005 Subaru Outback - even though I bought essentially the base model, it has all the features I like (power steering, A/C, power and heated seat, power mirrors. And AWD to boot!

I really like this car. It gets around very well. Gas mileage is good. I typically get 27-28 MPG in mixed driving. At 165,000 miles, I have yet to see any problem signs, but it had been very well taken care of by its previous owner. It is my understanding that Subarus in particular are very picky about routine maintenance- but if it is followed you have a vehicle with very few problems. Performance overall is ok. It's not the quickest in 0-60 and is not going to win any drag races. However, you will be able to merge with traffic easily and will be able to cruise all day at 80 mph without problems.