50 Best Buffalo Used Subaru Legacy for Sale, Savings from $3,079

2011 Subaru Legacy
83,775 Miles | North Tonawanda, NY
$9,595
est. $138/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
21,092 Miles | Hamburg, NY
$17,444
est. $251/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
62,832 Miles | Orchard Park, NY
$13,962
est. $201/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
24,061 Miles | Ransomville, NY
$16,924
est. $244/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2016 Subaru Legacy
68,325 Miles | Irving, NY
$15,968
est. $230/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2015 Subaru Legacy
55,997 Miles | Batavia, NY
$13,000
est. $187/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2015 Subaru Legacy
81,981 Miles | Batavia, NY
$13,000
est. $187/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
28,215 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$17,990
est. $259/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2016 Subaru Legacy
74,056 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$13,990
est. $202/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
31,520 Miles | Saint Louis, MO
$18,590
est. $268/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
66,419 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$14,990
est. $216/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
35,936 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$17,990
est. $259/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
19,775 Miles | Denver, CO
$23,690
est. $341/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
58,837 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$14,990
est. $216/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2018 Subaru Legacy
17,218 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$21,990
est. $317/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
73,489 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$14,590
est. $210/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2013 Subaru Legacy
41,337 Miles | Santa Fe Springs, CA
$14,990
est. $216/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
69,737 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$15,990
est. $230/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
41,267 Miles | Charlotte, NC
$15,590
est. $225/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
74,935 Miles | Rio Linda, CA
$14,990
est. $216/mo

Track Price Check Availability

Buffalo, NY Subaru Legacy Buyer's Guide

Owner Reviews
4.4
111 Reviews
Overall
4.4
Value
4.3
Performance
3.7
Style
3.9
Comfort
4.1
Fuel Economy
3.8
Reliability
4.2
Top Dealers In Buffalo, NY
  1. Matthews Subaru Vestal
  2. Bill Kolb Jr Subaru Orangeburg

Subaru Legacy Owner Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review
4.4
Overall
111 Reviews
View All

2000 Subaru Legacy - Love my Subaru

Kristy
Beacon, New York
Overall
5.0
Value
4.0
Performance
3.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Economy
4.0
Reliability
4.0
I have a 2000 Subaru Legacy sedan that I bought in 2003. I love the car. It is relatively sporty, at least, for a Subaru. It has been very reliable as evidenced by the fact that it is 17 years old and still drives well.
Story
Although some might think a Subaru sedan is too small, it can hold more than one might think. At one point I managed to fit a decent sized Christmas tree into the back seat!
Pros
I love that it is all-wheel drive and goes great in the snow as long as there is six inches or less, as it does sit relatively low to the ground. And it has relatively good gas mileage, considering it is all-wheel drive. The interior of the car, although inexpensive, has held up well (even with a toddler). Even though the small size can be a negative, it is also a positive. If you live in a city and need to find parking, it can fit in spots that other larger vehicles cannot.
Cons
There are of course a few negatives about the car. When I bought it, the speakers in the car did not work well out of one side. After having the original car radio replaced with a CD player/radio, the problem was fixed. For the past five years, the radio only works intermittently, but the CD player still works well. When I had a child, the obvious downside to the car was its size and low back seat. It was hard to get the car seat in and out of the car. Once we switched to a larger car seat that rarely gets moved, it was easier. Although, it's still not as easy as a van/SUV.

2007 Subaru Legacy - Perfect for Just About Anybody

Laura
Farmingville, New York
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Economy
4.0
Reliability
5.0
I have been the owner of a 2007 Subaru Legacy for five years. Old Blue has about 120,000 miles on it and has never let me down. This is the safest car I have ever owned by far. I never have to worry about it in bad weather. I love the features - the sunroof especially - and have no complaints about the look either. It looks sleek and I'm happy to spend time in it. The quality of this car is incredible. It is reliable, never had a major break down, and never left me stranded. I get good gas mileage, even though I drive in the city!
Story
My friends and I once packed out the Subaru and drove to the beach. The beach was too crowded so we got our beach chairs out and sat in the parking lot next to the car instead. The Subaru had all the space we needed to set up a little "buffet" in the trunk!
Pros
The best thing about the Subaru Legacy has to be its safety ratings. Considering how much time I spend in my car (over 3 hours per day!), it has to be safe and reliable. I never have to worry about bad weather - the Subaru never loses traction, even in terrible snow storms. I feel safe putting my family in the car. As a mother, nothing is more important to me than safety. I also love how reliable it is. I always take care of my car (regular oil changes and check ups) and issues are always diagnosed then before there is a problem. Outside of normal wear and tear, this vehicle has nev... (more)
Cons
I've noticed I get more flat tires in this car than any in the past. I sometimes feel like the car is too low to the ground as well.
View All Reviews

Buffalo, NY Subaru Legacy Pricing Analysis

Active Listings
Mileage

May 2020 Buffalo Subaru Legacy Prices & Rankings

Should you drive for a deal?
View Detailed Methodology

Cheap Subaru Legacy Areas in Buffalo, NY

Where is the cheapest place to buy a Subaru Legacy in Buffalo, NY?

Buffalo, NY Dealer Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review
2
Reviews

2002 Subaru Impreza - Bill Kolb Jr Subaru Orangeburg

BR
Orangeburg, New York
Overall
4.0
Facility
4.0
Process
5.0
Quality
4.0
Service
4.0
I actually had a good experience here. I would rather the place have been in a better location, rather than so far out of the way, but that's beyond the performance ability of the employees. Right? Overall, I am satisfied with the purchase and I might even buy from there again. I just wish they were closer. The salesman I worked with was pretty good and I did get a better price than what my goal was. I always start lower than what I'm willing to pay. Overall, I'm pretty satisfied with the experience and I would recommend it to a friend or family member.

2015 Subaru Forester - Matthews Subaru Vestal

NT
Binghamton University, New York
Overall
5.0
Facility
5.0
Process
5.0
Quality
5.0
Service
5.0
What made this dealership so great? Rob Finta. He's a not a cheating sales guy, wants to help you get into the vehicle you are looking for. Doesn't try to upsell or hassle you. When you are trying to make a vehicle decision he will ask you questions to make you actually think about your needs and what you are looking for instead of trying to put you into the most expensive model on the floor. He is also very quick on responding to any inquiries and provides timely status updates, both before and after the purchase of the vehicle. The service department also goes out of their way to help you with any issues you run.

Similar Models in Buffalo, NY