2005 Subaru Legacy
148,115 Miles
$6,991

Spokane, WA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
115,863 Miles
$6,995

Lakeside, CA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
180,535 Miles
$6,588

Gresham, OR
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
69,885 Miles
$8,499

Morton Grove, IL
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
86,367 Miles
$4,950

Hampden, MA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
154,768 Miles
$5,350

Owensboro, KY
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
50,023 Miles
$8,963

Williamsville, NY
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
74,058 Miles
$7,911

Mechanicsburg, PA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
102,591 Miles
$10,440

Mequon, WI
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
147,954 Miles
$4,995

Englewood, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
155,826 Miles
$5,994

Denver, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
124,298 Miles
$7,900

Denver, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
125,131 Miles
$5,500

Columbus, OH
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
181,000 Miles
$7,999

Springfield, OR
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
153,313 Miles
$4,995

Corona, CA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
130,152 Miles
$5,900

Wakefield, RI
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
206,315 Miles
$4,500

Centennial, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
59,666 Miles
$12,980

Denver, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
116,164 Miles
$7,000

Boulder, CO
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy
113,127 Miles
$7,998

Yakima, WA
Track Price Check Availability

2005 Subaru Legacy Buyer's Guide

Owner Reviews
4.5
2 Reviews
Overall
4.5
Value
4.0
Performance
4.0
Style
3.5
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
3.5
Reliability
3.0

2005 Subaru Legacy Owner Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review

2005 Subaru Legacy - Love my Subaru

Michelle
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
3.0
Reliability
5.0
My 2005 Subaru Legacy recently hit 100,000 miles. During the seven years that I've owned this vehicle, I have always felt safe while driving, due to the all-wheel drive, dual airbags, and Subaru's high safety ratings. I love that my car looks like a slightly sporty sedan. The interior features I most enjoy are the moon roof, leather upholstery, heated seats, and power windows and seating. My Subaru is also fun to drive! I enjoy how it hugs curves and can speed up quickly or stop on a dime. I have it serviced regularly and thus far have only had routine maintenance (replacing tires, brakes, air filters, etc.). Although I love this particular make and model, I will probably purchase a Subaru that is not quite as low to the ground as the Legacy. I have moved to a more rural area and somet... (more)
Story
I am considered an essential employee at my job, which means I have to come in even in inclement weather. I have watched other people struggle to get their steering under control or to make it up the relatively steep hills on our campus, while I have never had an issue navigating in ice, snow, or wet conditions.
Pros
Long-lasting: My 2005 Subaru Legacy recently hit 100,000 miles. Safe: During the seven years that I've owned this vehicle, I have always felt safe while driving, due to the all-wheel drive, dual airbags, and Subaru's high safety ratings. Appearance: I love that my car looks like a slightly sporty sedan. The interior features I most enjoy are the moon roof, leather upholstery, heated seats, and power windows and seating. Driving experience: My Subaru is also fun to drive! I enjoy how it hugs curves and can speed up quickly or stop on a dime. Reasonable maintenance: I have it serviced regul... (more)
Cons
The Subaru Legacy sedan sits lower than I'd like. Sometimes the undercarriage gets scraped on rough/uneven terrain. It is also so low that my parents sometimes have a little trouble getting up out of the seats.

2005 Subaru Legacy - I have loved this car, but it hasn't aged well

Alexis
Louisville, Kentucky
Overall
4.0
Value
3.0
Performance
4.0
Style
2.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
4.0
Reliability
1.0
I love my Subaru Legacy. When I bought her, I felt like she was stylish, she drove well, and was comfortable for long drives alone or with a car full of friends. I was very disappointed when I a computer sensor associated with sensing acceleration stopped working and had to be replaced (difficult to figure out this was the issue and quite costly). It is also very finicky with fluids and oil. I once went to a general place to get my fluids changed, and I had to take my car back to a Subaru dealership to get the proper fluids because the car was not driving correctly. In the past years (~50,000 miles) I've had to have the power steering fluid holder replaced *twice* as well the brushings, bearings, timing belt (but I knew this was expected), and need to have the catalytic converted... (more)
Story
My Subaru has driven my off to college, back home for grad school, and away again for my first job. My co-pilots have included three boyfriends, more friends than I can count, and the sweetest pet cockatiel. She's moved brides, graduates, and parents-to-be, and has traveled from Chicago to New York, Ft. Lauderdale, and Birmingham. When I got it ten years ago, I envisioned driving my future k... (more)
Pros
I've been so happy with this car when it is running well. Maybe I got a lemon? My sister has a 2006 Subaru Legacy, and she had not had many of the same problems that I've had (e.g. the sensor, the steering fluid issues). I love how roomy the car is when travelling with friends and family and how comfortable it is for long (5-8+) hour drives. The trunk has always been large enough to fit anything I've needed to move. I especially love the intermittent windshield wiper setting.
Cons
I feel like it is not holding up well in it's old age (11 years, ~120,000 miles). I've had to have quite a few repairs over the past few years, probably totaling to more than the car is worth.

2005 Subaru Legacy Pricing Analysis

Active Listings
Mileage

May 2018 Nationwide Subaru Legacy Prices