50 Best 2009 Subaru Legacy for Sale, Savings from $2,289

2009 Subaru Legacy
100,528 Miles | Waukesha, WI
$9,998
est. $144/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
113,303 Miles | Merrillville, IN
$9,599
est. $138/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
152,705 Miles | Mckinney, TX
$4,900
est. $71/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
95,979 Miles | Binghamton, NY
$7,000
est. $101/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
97,057 Miles | Carson City, NV
$8,995
est. $130/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
100,611 Miles | Cherryville, PA
$5,900
est. $85/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
209,259 Miles | Emmaus, PA
$4,995
est. $72/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
102,528 Miles | Knoxville, TN
$5,650
est. $81/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
126,719 Miles | North Bend, WA
$6,931
est. $100/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
166,062 Miles | Fayetteville, AR
$6,500
est. $94/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
111,077 Miles | Storrs, CT
$7,999
est. $115/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
100,477 Miles | Storrs, CT
$7,497
est. $108/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
141,138 Miles | Storrs, CT
$8,375
est. $121/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
110,334 Miles | Adamstown, PA
$7,495
est. $108/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
175,330 Miles | Knoxville, TN
$4,500
est. $65/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
166,251 Miles | Hartford, WI
$4,995
est. $72/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
148,579 Miles | West Palm Beach, FL
$5,025
est. $72/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
118,341 Miles | Chantilly, VA
$5,900
est. $85/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
80,620 Miles | Bloomington, IN
$8,995
est. $130/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy
86,043 Miles | Wells, ME
$6,490
est. $94/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2009 Subaru Legacy Buyer's Guide

Owner Reviews
5.0
2 Reviews
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
4.5
Comfort
4.5
Fuel Economy
4.5
Reliability
5.0

2009 Subaru Legacy Owner Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review

2009 Subaru Legacy - Best car ever

BG
Renton, Washington
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
5.0
Style
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
5.0
Reliability
5.0
This car has consistently exceeded my expectations from the day I got it. I was so happy to buy this car and even though it has had one major repair, it has run like a dream and gets decent gas mileage as well. I plan to drive this car into the ground, so I'm looking to put at least 200k more miles on it which will make it very worth the amount I paid.
Story
Driving all the way to California 800+ miles
Pros
Dependable Great gas mileage Looks great Interior Sunroof
Cons
Head gaskets are a problem in Subaru's

2009 Subaru Legacy - Reliable and fits my personality.

Dawn
Hayward, California
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
3.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Economy
4.0
Reliability
5.0
The car was purchased used with only 9,000 miles so it was in perfect condition still. I love that it's a deep red, not an ugly red, even though that's superficial. I don't like flashy cars, and this is a very practical vehicle. The engine runs well, although I do wish it had a little bit more power. Sometimes accelerating onto the freeway seems like a struggle, and it is not meant for hauling heavy loads. I also wish it had a trailer hitch and a rear windshield wiper, since I have to clean the rear windshield myself when it gets dirty, and the trailer hitch would allow for a good bike rack. The spoiler on the car keeps it from looking too old-school. The car is compact but spacious enough inside for me as a 5’9” tall person. I have been able to transport large items such as dining tab... (more)
Story
I took the car camping once in the fall, and once I pitched the tent on site and stepped back to take a photo of my cute campsite, I realized it looked just like a Subaru advertisement! The sun was shining through the leaves, which matched the red of my car, and I felt like I was using the Subaru the way it is marketed -- for having fun, outdoor experiences.
Pros
One of my favorite features, while not the most important, is the color. I like red cars, but it is a deep red, so it's not too sporty or flashy. I also know that Subarus are durable and reliable, and so far, this has been true, even though I've only had it or five years, but I have had no issues whatsoever with adding 30,000 miles to it, including a cross-country drive. I like that the car is practical without looking too old, partly because of the spoiler. It looks really nice when waxed. The audio system is pretty good for a car, and the auxiliary cord plug-in is a must for me. I also p... (more)
Cons
I do wish the car had more power...sometimes accelerating onto the freeway seems like a bit of a struggle, and hauling a carload full of boxes out of my apartment for a cross-country move really brought down the car's performance. I couldn't go much faster than 65 miles an hour, and going up hills required slowing to 50 or so to prevent the RPMs from spiking. However, since the car is a sedan, I understand that it isn't meant for hauling. Even though the car is spacious, sometimes the ceiling over the driver's seat rubs the top of my head if I sit in certain ways, so it might be good to ha... (more)

2009 Subaru Legacy Pricing Analysis

Active Listings
Mileage

January 2020 Nationwide Subaru Legacy Prices