50 Best 2011 Subaru Legacy for Sale, Savings from $3,489

2011 Subaru Legacy
74,500 Miles | Hartford, CT
$12,599
est. $182/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
59,470 Miles | Virginia Beach, VA
$12,599
est. $182/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
151,430 Miles | Turnersville, NJ
$5,495
est. $79/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
118,595 Miles | Bristol, TN
$8,188
est. $118/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
151,388 Miles | Okarche, OK
$6,500
est. $94/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
142,386 Miles | Voorhees, NJ
$5,990
est. $86/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
26,209 Miles | State College, PA
$12,988
est. $187/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
136,528 Miles | Lake Saint Louis, MO
$7,895
est. $114/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
104,250 Miles | Alpharetta, GA
$7,495
est. $108/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
141,911 Miles | Arlington, VA
$5,981
est. $86/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
223,983 Miles | Milwaukee, WI
$3,444
est. $50/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
122,796 Miles | Barron, WI
$7,640
est. $110/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
102,440 Miles | York, PA
$7,500
est. $108/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
101,297 Miles | Clearwater, FL
$7,733
est. $111/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
116,619 Miles | Seaford, DE
$5,497
est. $79/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
114,355 Miles | Hattiesburg, MS
$9,800
est. $141/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
54,736 Miles | Milwaukee, WI
$9,451
est. $136/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
92,127 Miles | Norwalk, CT
$8,800
est. $127/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
167,734 Miles | Plaistow, NH
$4,950
est. $71/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
121,924 Miles | Alliance, OH
$7,900
est. $114/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy Buyer's Guide

Owner Reviews
4.8
4 Reviews
Overall
4.8
Value
4.8
Performance
4.0
Style
4.3
Comfort
4.5
Fuel Economy
3.8
Reliability
4.8

2011 Subaru Legacy Owner Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review

2011 Subaru Legacy - 2011 Subaru Legacy Limited 3.6R

Jeremy
Neenah, Wisconsin
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
3.0
Reliability
5.0
The Subaru brand, as a whole, goes out of its way to make sure that they are delivering a superior product to their loyal owners. Knowing this, the Subaru Legacy quickly became not only a car that I wanted, but a car that I had to own. I fell in love with it the first time I ever sat in one, and the vehicle itself drove me crazy. When I finally got the opportunity to actually drive one, especially this trim level, I was blown away. This vehicle has symmetrical all-wheel drive that will get you into or out of any situation you desire, is incredibly stylish, has room for five people and all of their stuff, leather trim, great audio, and is incredibly reliable. With regular maintenance, this car should last well over 200,000 miles. I would buy this car 100 times over, and I even managed t... (more)
Story
I took a trip across the country to visit my late father's grave with my wife, my sister, and her boyfriend. We packed four people, a week's worth of equipment, and $100 worth of beer into the car, and traveled almost 2,000 miles. We averaged an incredible 29 MPG on that trip across the country, and the only complaint was that it got a little warm. The car performed wonderfully, had plenty of ... (more)
Pros
There are a number of things to love about this vehicle, but the top items for me are the cargo space, engine, leather trim, and symmetrical all-wheel drive. When I started shopping for a new vehicle, I knew that something with a great deal of cargo space was very important. I had no desire for a truck or SUV, so a large Sedan was the next best choice. I found that the Subaru Legacy had much more than expected cargo room and am constantly surprised at what will fit into the vehicle. Next is the engine. This vehicle comes with the optional and powerful 3.6L H6 engine. This engine pushes out... (more)
Cons
Writing any negative things about this vehicle is incredibly difficult, but a few specific items pop up. The largest drawbacks are the gas mileage, the infotainment center, and wood veneer trim. While generally sedans in this class have great gas mileage, and other trim levels of this model have great gas mileage. The combination of the five-speed automatic transmission and 3.6L H6 engine make this vehicle go through its 16.1 gallon gas tank quite quickly. Highway averages are 28 mpg, and city averages are 22 mpg. Combined in ideal (warm) conditions, expect to see around 25 mpg. In the win... (more)

2011 Subaru Legacy - A great rude.

Legacy Owner
Lowell, Massachusetts
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
5.0
Reliability
5.0
The Subaru Legacy is the best choice car for a New England resident. The vehicle gets great gas mileage, handles well in snow and rain, and it is dependable in any weather condition. Not only do you get dependability, but you also get a well-balanced vehicle that handles well in both speed and turning. The body is well made and can withstand the elements. No matter the weather, you will feel safe when you are driving this vehicle. I never expected that I would be a Subaru driving in the future, but once I bought this car after my Honda ran its course, I was very satisfied with the results. If I could, I would buy this vehicle again soon. I strongly recommend anyone who needs a new car to buy a Legacy immediately for the efficient design and well-balanced operation of the car. If you ca... (more)
Story
I went on a trip to Maine in this car to see friends for a weekend. The ride up was quick in that the vehicle made top speed while also being reasonable on gas. I barely saw the tank go below half a tank. That is dependability for a vehicle. In being able to keep fuel down while going so fast on the highway, I got to my destination in record time. I am satisfied with what I have done with this... (more)
Pros
The Subaru Legacy gets right to the point in gas mileage. I have gone miles on just half a tank of gas. Mass to Maine and Maine to Mass in a weekend did not affect the performance of the vehicle in any way, shape, or form. I got the most for my money with this vehicle. In terms of handling, this car is dream. From bad snow to heavy downpours, this car will stay on the road and not be a threat to you or anyone else. It provides comfort, dependability, and safety when hazards are considered. The cost to repair the vehicle is very low maintenance and there are no worries on spending too much ... (more)
Cons
The paint job of the vehicle leaves much to be desired. While I like the bronze, I would have liked more options. Overall, I cannot say there are any standing problems with this vehicle. I have not had a negative experience with it and I am satisfied with the performance of the car. It is difficult to fault this vehicle for any purpose besides nitpicking. This is a dependable vehicle that is and will continue to serve me well in the coming months. I may end up selling this car, but that will not be for another few years until I get the most out of this vehicle. I do not want to give up a c... (more)

2011 Subaru Legacy - Solid car with adequate power

Holly
Milo, Maine
Overall
4.0
Value
4.0
Performance
3.0
Style
3.0
Comfort
3.0
Fuel Economy
3.0
Reliability
4.0
The 2011 Subaru Legacy is a good all weather car with decent power and handling characteristics. The power to weight ratio is a little lean, but sufficient for every day driving, even in a climate where I live - Central Maine. The all-wheel-drive powertrain supplies enough grip that I was safe all winter on icy and snowy back roads. This would not be a good car for towing a boat or anything that has a decent amount of weight to it. The body panels are too lightweight and dent easy, especially in parking lots where you might encounter the odd shopping cart ding. The interior trim material on the door panels is extremely thin and likely to scratch and tear if you have pets that travel with you. The seats are extremely comfortable but very difficult to maintain as they have endless places... (more)
Story
I drove this car all the way to Mexico City and back. Even on the back roads of Mexico, this car performed flawlessly.
Pros
Good power, strong drivetrain, all-wheel drive, heated seats, heated external mirrors, good MPG performance
Cons
Thin body panels, high road noise, feels sluggish at times

2011 Subaru Legacy Pricing Analysis

Active Listings
Mileage

April 2020 Nationwide Subaru Legacy Prices